Best K Cups For Keurig Coffee Makers - Top 10 Reviewed

If you’re in a hurry and just want to find out what the best k cups are then our top pick is the Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cups.

Want to enjoy the best coffee at home but not interested in griding and tampering for each cup?

Yup…We know how you feel. K cups might be the perfect solution for you.

Why?

Single-serves offer quick and easy caffeine fixes, from Italian roast through to dark house blend shots, K-Cups can satisfy all your caffeine needs!

They make the experience easy by making just one drink at a time via a press of a button.

But with all the K-Cups on the market, it can be hard to determine which is the best for you, so let’s help you out and give you all the info you need.

Review Picks Top 3

Best K Cups for Keurig Buying Guide

Today, one in every three US homes has a Keurig machine and use K-cups regularly!

With the increase in popularity, there has been an increase in the number of manufacturers that make K-cups. Coffee lovers are finding it more challenging than ever to find the flavors and tastes that they prefer.

There are many things to consider when buying the best K Cups and how you use them.

Considerations When Choosing the Best K Cups Coffee

There are some crucial points you need to be aware of when searching for the best single serve coffees.

We have put together a list below for ease:

Ingredients

Coffee is the primary ingredient in a K-Cup, but there can be a few other ingredients as well, so be aware of this.

If you’re buying a flavored k cups, you will notice there some additives, and some of these you might not be a fan of, so check before buying!

Typically, brands will add other ingredients to the coffee only if required. Make sure you are getting a product that has the ingredients you want, so you can enjoy a brew that you genuinely love.

Coffee Type

You might know there are two types of beans, either Robusta or Arabica.

Of the two, Arabica is thought to give you higher-quality coffee when compared to Robusta, which contains around double the caffeine content.

With a wide range of K-Cups on the market, you have a better chance of narrowing down your choice to coffee, which fits your bean preference.

Quantity

Quality is always emphasized in commercials, but you also need to consider the quantity that you are purchasing.

You want to make sure you are getting a good value for the money, so consider how much you can get for the price that is being asked.

Flavor

Typically, top brands will have a unique signature flavor (e.g breakfast blend or Italian roast).

Depending on your tastes, different flavors will suit you better than other people. Just make sure to find the flavor that you desire the best when choosing K-Cups.

k cup coffee

K Cups Expiration Date

K-cup coffees come with an expiration date, which is the day the product is best used sold by.

After this date, the quality of the product is no longer guaranteed. So, technically, while they do have an expiration date, but that doesn’t mean that they are unfit to consume. It just indicates that the quality won’t be as good.

There are a few things you can do to prolong the K-Cup’s lifespan so that you can ensure the initial quality of the coffee is maintained.

There are a few things you can do to prolong the K-Cup’s lifespan so that you can ensure the initial quality of the coffee is maintained. 
  •  Never expose the K-Cup to direct sunlight, which negatively affects your coffee’s quality
  •  Do not expose the K-Cups to temperature fluctuations

Tips to Make The Best Coffee From K Cups

Brew smaller cups

If you’re making a larger brew, you will notice a weaker flavor.

Instead of using a 12 oz cup for a tall black go with a 6 oz cup. Get an intense boost in your flavor through this easy alteration.

Keep the Machine Clean

The taste of coffee can change over time when bacteria accumulates in the coffee machine.

To keep this from happening, every couple of months, pass one cup of white vinegar through the machine. Then, wash it by adding a cup or two of water after.

This will give you a revitalized your machine and you can start to brew amazing k cups again.

Shake It

Shake the pod before you put it into the machine.

Shaking is particularly crucial for a flavored K cup since flavors tend to settle down at the bottom.

With just a quick shake, similar to shaking a bottle of juice, you can evenly distribute the flavors, giving you a more smooth brew.

Two Pods

If you enjoy the Keruig tall drink settings but dislike the weak flavor, double up your pods and cut your water by half!

Meaning, brew 2 K Cups on the lowest setting and enjoy the maximum flavor with a caffeinated kick!

Add a Pinch of Salt

Bitter coffee?…No one likes that! If you’ve investigated and figured its not your grounds which are responsible, then try some salt!

While it can seem odd, just a pinch of salt will help to revitalize your drink while overcoming any bitterness in the K cup.

Don’t add more than a pinch since too much salt will just make your drink taste odd!

Start the Water Cycle

After you use a Keurig, you will find that the sediment-water will probably be cool, which can lower your brewing temperature.

Before you start to brew, heat the water and machine by starting the water cycle. This makes the water warmer and gives you the best brewing temperature.

Remove Your Drink Early

When you get down to the last few seconds of brewing, you often find that the coffee has become too diluted and weak.

To make sure you get the most out of your coffee, take the cup of coffee out of the machine while it is still dripping.

Also, always make sure you take a few minutes to clean out the tank so that your coffee remains undiluted and robust.

Try Filtered water

While tap water doesn’t taste that bad, it can cause sediment and minerals to accumulate in your machine, which can affect its taste. Try filtered water!

Take Out the K cups Immediately

Don’t let K cups sit in the machine after its done brewing.

Take it out right away. When you leave a cup in the machine, it can cause a large amount of sediment to accumulate.

Read the instructions

I know..No one likes reading these things, but they can be useful…Sometimes!

Always make sure to get a quick overview, at the very least, of the instruction manual.

It may help you to discover if you are brewing the coffee wrong, which is causing you to have a weak cup of coffee.

Take a few minutes to read the instruction book, so you can make sure you have read all the tips to make your Keurig work effectively.

Create your own k cups

That’s right. You can create the best k cups yourself instead of praying and hoping a new flavor you try works out.
How?

All you need is to buy a re-useable k cup and add your own ground beans! Create your very own house blend by mixing your own grounds if you wish!

This process gives you complete control (and blame if it doesn’t taste good!).

Our Top 10 Picks For Best K Cups for Keurig machines

Below we run through a few tips and reviews of our top 10 single serves to help you find the best K Cups available today.

Overall Top Pick
5/5

Made from 100% Arabica coffee, Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cup Pods are a potent blend.

Part of their Heritage Collection, this coffee is incredibly dark, distinctively rich, and never bitter. Featuring full-bodied, earthy notes, Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cups have a deep flavor.

The Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cups can be used in any type of K-Cup machine.

It’s best enjoyed black since it has almost no bitterness.

Pros

  • Great tasting dark roast with almost no bitterness
  • Exceptional if you enjoy your coffee black

Cons

  • Expensive
Best Light Roast
4/5

The breakfast blend Keurig K Cup coffees are a light to medium roast, featuring a nutty flavor with balanced sweetness.

These K-Cups are compatible with any Keurig Single Serve Coffee Maker to give you a light roast when you need it.

Bright and clean, Green Mountain Breakfast Blend K-Cups are made with 100% Arabica coffee.

Using no artificial ingredients, every K-Cup comes with fresh ground coffee that will make the perfect brew each time.

It’s also a certified Orthodox Union Kosher product.

Pros

  • Green Mountain has good flavor and is not too strong
  • From a socially responsible company

Cons

  • Expensive vs other k cups
  • Some users note these single serves don’t work with all Keurig machines

Peet’s Major Dickason’s Blend K-Cup is a dark roast made from high-quality beans sourced from growers all over the world.

Giving a flavorful and rich taste, roasted by true artisans roasting the coffee by hand in small batches.

Luckily, Inside each Peet’s K-Cups is the same quality that you would find in their ground beans!

Pros

  • It has the perfect balance of smooth and bold
  • No compromise on taste vs ground beans from Peet’s

Cons

  • The packaging isn’t recyclable

Flavorful, bold, and fresh, The Original Donut Shop Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup coffee pods are specifically designed to work in all Keurig machines.

This regular medium roast isn’t too bitter or harsh but extra bold. 

The Original Donut Shop Coffee reminds you of the americano you might drink while enjoying your favorite donut. 

Each pod ensures a high-quality drink each time and features exact extraction and grind to work perfectly with your Keurig.

Pros

  • A tasty classic
  • They always work well  with all Keurig machines

Cons

  • They are pretty expensive per unit for what you get
  • It can take twice as long to brew as other K-Cups

This package features K-cups made for use in any Keurig machine.

Delivering that signature taste everyone loves, Dunkin’ Donuts Original Blend Medium Roast is a flavorful and smooth brew in these handy K Cups.

With full-bodied flavor, this is a specially roasted and blended coffee that gives you that Dunkin’ Donuts taste at home.

This medium roast coffee is made from premium Arabica beans that are selected to provide consistent smooth and delicious flavor at home.

Made for use for any Keurig K-Cup machine, you can also use Dunkin’ Donuts K Cups to get creative and make cappuccinos if you have the right machine or add ons!

Pros

  • Perfect for Dunkin Donut lovers!
  • The K-Cups are always consistent with their quality

Cons

  • They are on the expensive side
Budget Pick
4/5

These Solimo pods are Amazon’s own brand and compatible with both the Keurig 1.0 and 2.0 K Cups.

Made with pure Arabica beans only, this dark roast coffee has bold and flavorful. 

A Full-bodied coffee, the Amazon Brand Dark Roast, has a mild acidity with a hearty punch and a smooth finish.

Pros

  • You’ll love this if you like something with a kick
  • Excellent value
  • The K-Cups work well with all types of Keurig machines

Cons

  • Slow to brew due to low-quality pods

This Light Roast features a Caramel Vanilla Cream flavor that is a decadent blend toasty brown sugar, creamy vanilla, and buttery caramel flavors.

Green Mountain Coffee Roaster K-cups are designed to give you a richer and better-tasting brew with a sweet after taste.

Certified Orthodox Union Kosher, this light roast guarantees a high-quality cup with each pod. Every Green Mountain single-serve K-Cup pod is filled with the freshest ground coffee to give you a great-tasting coffee each time you make it.

Pros

  • Great if you have a sweet tooth
  • Makes a nice treat if not a daily driver

Cons

  • Some machines overflow and brew slowly with these k cups

Tully’s Coffee French Roast K-Cup offers single-serve dark roast coffee pods.

Featuring a decadent and smoky take on a popular roast, the French roast is intense and powerful with a bittersweet end.

Tully’s coffee is slow-roasted to coax out the complex aromas and flavors from the coffee beans. Rooted in the Pacific Northwest, Tully’s uses an artisanal approach to create a full-bodied and satisfying cup.

This is a dark roast that is also Orthodox Union Kosher.

Pros

  • Great if you have a sweet tooth
  • Makes a nice treat if not a daily driver

Cons

  • Some machines overflow and brew slowly with these k cups

Available in an 80-count pack, the SF Bay Coffee French Roast is a dark roast with an intense and smoky taste.

This K-Cup has an interesting packaging as its a compostable coffee pod made with degradable materials.

Including a mesh coffee filter, paper lidding, and a plant-based ring. It’s also compatible with most K-Cup brewers that include the Keurig 2.0.

SF Bay Coffee is committed to the continual progression of coffee farming and practicing sustainability and innovation. Offering fair trade to farmers, they also work to minimize waste while still giving you’re the best coffee.

With a blend of coffees from South and Central America, this French roast is roasted until all the flavor oils rise to the bean’s surface to give the coffee a full-bodied taste with a smoky finish.

Certified fully commercial compostable by BPI, this is a Kosher coffee that is ground and packed fresh.

Pros

  • This is excellent coffee which comes with an attractive price
  • A small and family-owned company

Cons

  • Prone to leakage in the earlier Keurig machines

These single-serve K-Cup Pods feature a medium roast made with 100% Arabica coffee. 

Laughing Man Hugh’s Blend comes is fair trade certified and works with any Keurig Single-Serve K-Cup Coffee Maker.

Providing complementary but contrasting notes of toasted graham cracker and tart green apple, this balanced and smooth blend comes in a recycle K-cup.

Filled with fresh ground coffee that will brew into a perfect cup of coffee each time, Laughing Man High’s Blend K-Cups are Certified Orthodox Union Kosher.

Pros

  • The company gives back to the community
  • These are recyclable cups with good flavor

Cons

  • Grounds are too thin for some machines leading to leakage

Summary

Our recommendation for the best K-Cup coffee for Keurig is the Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cups. 

Part of their Heritage Collection, the Gevalia K-Cup Pods, are made from 100% Arabica coffee. This coffee is incredibly dark, distinctively rich, and never bitter.

Featuring full-bodied, earthy notes, Gevalia Majestic Roast K-Cups have a bold and deep flavor and can be used in any type of K-Cup machine.

This makes the best cups to drink black since it has almost no bitterness.
The clear winner of the best K Cups for Keurig coffee makers hands down!

Tips to Make The Best Coffee From K Cups

Brew At Lower Settings

If you’re making a larger brew, you will notice a weaker flavor.

Instead of using a 12 oz cup for a tall black go with a 6 oz cup. Get an intense boost in your flavor through this easy alteration.

Keep the Machine Clean

The taste of coffee can change over time when bacteria accumulate in the coffee machine.

To keep this from happening, every couple of months, pass one cup of white vinegar through the machine. Then, wash it by adding a cup or two of water after.

Giving you a revitalized machine to help you start brewing amazing k cups again.

Shake It

Shake the pod before you put it into the machine.

Shaking is particularly crucial for a flavored K cup since flavors tend to settle down at the bottom.

With just a quick shake, similar to shaking a bottle of juice, you can evenly distribute the flavors, giving you a more smooth brew.

Try Two Pods

If you enjoy the Keruig tall drink settings but dislike the weak flavor, double up your pods and cut your water by half!

Meaning, brew 2 K Cups on the lowest setting and enjoy the maximum flavor with a caffeinated kick!

add a pinch of salt

Bitter coffee?…No one likes that! If you’ve investigated and figured its not your grounds which are responsible, then try some salt!

While it can seem odd, just a pinch of salt will help to revitalize your drink while overcoming any bitterness in the K cup.

Don’t add more than a pinch since too much salt will just make your drink taste odd!

Start the Water Cycle

After you use a Keurig, you will find that the reservoir water will probably be cool, which can lower your brewing temperature.

Before you start to brew, heat the water and machine by starting the water cycle early. This makes the water warmer and gives you the best brewing temperature.

remove the cup early

When you get down to the last few seconds of brewing, you often find that the coffee has become too diluted and weak.

To make sure you get the most out of your coffee, take the cup of coffee out of the machine while it is still dripping.

Also, always make sure you take a few minutes to clean out the tank so that your coffee remains undiluted and robust.

Filtered Water

While tap water doesn’t taste that bad, it can cause sediment and minerals to accumulate in your machine, which can affect its taste. 

Try filtered water!

take out the k cups immediately after use

Don’t let K Cups sit in the machine after its done brewing.

Take it out right away. When you leave a cup in the machine, it can cause a large amount of sediment to accumulate.

read the instructions

I know..No one likes reading these things, but they can be useful…Sometimes!

Always make sure to get a quick overview, at the very least, of the instruction manual.

It may help you to discover if you are brewing the coffee wrong, which is causing you to have a weak cup of coffee.

Take a few minutes to read the instruction book, so you can make sure you have read all the tips to make your Keurig work effectively.

Create your own K Cups

That’s right. 

You can create the best k cups yourself instead of praying and hoping a new flavor you try works out.

How?

All you need is to buy a re-useable k cup and add your own ground beans! Create your very own house blend by mixing your own grounds if you wish!

This process gives you complete control (and blame if it doesn’t taste good!).

Advantages and disadvantages of k cups

Advantages

  1. Convenience – The main benefit of a Keurig is that you get a one serving preparation of great coffee in under a minute. Providing speedy results, you get coffee with minimal cleaning that is pretty much maintenance-free. K-Cups are inarguably the most convenient in the morning to get your day going.
  2. Versatilty – With all kinds of tastes, strengths, and profiles, the best K Cups allow you to drink whatever flavor you prefer easily. Enjoy a french roast but also partial to a sweet vanilla shot? No problem..K Cups give you the flexibility when you need it.
  3. Avoids waste – Everyone has made a large pot of coffee at some time, thinking they would drink it and then ended up forgetting all about it. Instead of throwing money away, just brew one pod at a time and not waste money on coffee you don’t consume.
  4. Less equipment – Many people use a Keurig as a backup, but it can work well as the main coffee maker in your home. This is an excellent option for those that live in a little apartment and want to reduce the amount of equipment they have on their counter. All you really need is a Keurig machine to enjoy coffee conveniently.
  5. Value – If you compare the cost of a pack of K-Cups to your regular Starbucks trips, you can see that using the pods is cost-effective. You won’t, of course, have the same ambiance that you get at a coffee shop, but you won’t have to leave the house or stand in line to get great tasting coffee.

Disadvantages

  1. Not Always Eco-Friendly – Since Keurig machines use a disposable pod design, they’re not considered a very environmentally friendly brewing choice. When these pods are manufactured, they tend to use a lot of plastic that make some people concerned about how they affect the environment. Always look for K-cups that have an eco-friendly design if that is important to you.
  2. Expensive – In comparison to other home brewing methods, K-Cups are more expensive. Especially if you drink a lot of coffee throughout the day, counter this by using a dual coffee maker to allow you to make a large pot if required and k cups otherwise.
  3. Limited Choice – When comparing the choice is available for the best ground beans to those in K-Cups, you will realize that the K Cups choices are more limited overall.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *